Tough Love and Cruelty

Where does that line exist?

We stand our best chance of leaving a legacy to those who want to learn, our children, by standing firm. In matters of style, hey, swing with the stream. But in matters of principle, you need to stand like a rock.

Kevin Costner

Got a question or message for "Hey Dad"? Submit it anonymously!

I understand the importance of privacy and want to make it easy for you to reach out. You can submit your questions or messages completely anonymously using this form. Just click the link below. I look forward to hearing from you!

Submit Your Anonymous Message Here

---

Am I Being Tough? Or Cruel?

Ah, dear children, my heart has long been burdened with a weight that, though unseen, presses heavily upon my very soul. I find myself torn between the instincts I have inherited, the hard-won lessons life has branded upon my spirit, and the deep, sacred duty I feel toward you—my dearest ones, the tender fruits of my life, fragile and vulnerable, yet brimming with boundless potential.

It is a weight born from love, yet intertwined with fear, worry, sorrow, and regret. How often do I ask myself: Am I guiding you rightly, or am I, in my fervor, leaving scars instead?

There are nights—oh, so many nights—when I watch you, silent and serene in sleep, caught in the fragile peace that only children know. And in those moments, I am both comforted and tormented.

I am comforted by the reminder of your innocence, yet tormented by the endless questions that haunt me: Do my efforts uplift you, or am I, without even realizing it, pushing you down? Is my strength enough to shield you, or am I casting a shadow that might one day block your own light?

These are questions that lie in wait, re-emerging from the dark recesses of my heart at every moment of silence.

There is no guidebook for this task, no compass to direct me, and certainly no promise of certainty. Instead, there exists only a nebulous, ever-shifting line—one I must tread with the utmost care. And yet, despite all my efforts, sometimes I feel myself straying.

A voice within me warns of boundaries I cannot see, ones I fear crossing and damaging your hearts without realizing. At times, I am struck by a dull ache that tells me I may have overstepped, taken a wrong turn, or pressed too hard on that invisible threshold.

When I left the Marines, I carried with me a spirit tempered by fire, molded in hardship, and steeped in an unforgiving world. In that world, strength was essential, for survival demanded nothing less.

There, we learned to strip ourselves of weakness, to discard sentimentality, and to forge resilience from the raw materials of suffering and grit. We were shaped by harsh hands that believed in fortifying the spirit through trials.

This was not cruelty, you see, but necessity—a crucible that forged men capable of enduring storms that would break others. And now, in this quiet life of family and love, I find myself wrestling with those same instincts, wondering if they are fit for the tender souls in my care.

For you, dear ones, did not sign up for such trials. No, you arrived in my life as if carried by a gentle breeze, unbroken, untouched by the harsher winds that shaped me. You sought my protection, my wisdom, my love.

And yet, time and again, I struggle to offer that love unguarded, without the roughness that once shielded me.

It is a tormenting paradox, this desire to pass on my strength without passing on the scars, to prepare you for a world that often lacks mercy without making your home one that does the same.

In moments of exasperation, I catch myself pushing you, urging you to reach higher, move faster, accomplish more, even when you may not be ready for the climb. When does a gentle nudge become a shove?

My mind wrestles with this, replaying moments where perhaps I pressed too hard, where I saw a spark in you and tried, maybe desperately, to kindle it into a flame without letting it grow at its own pace.

I see in you such brilliance, such unique beauty, and I long to guide it, to foster it. Yet I know that the weight of my expectations could crush rather than nurture if I am not careful.

I know the feeling too well, that knot that tightens in my stomach each time I question my approach. There is a cruel irony to it all—the very one who strives to lead you toward clarity stumbles, feeling as lost and uncertain as you.

I have pushed you, I know, toward goals that perhaps were mine to bear alone. I have asked you to hold my dreams, even as I questioned whether they were truly yours to hold.

And now, in the quiet moments, I cannot escape the relentless question: Did I harm in my hope to heal? Did I hinder when I meant to help?

In my mind's eye, I see the years stretching ahead and feel a deep pang of fear—that by asking too much, I could drive you away. This fear gnaws at me, and I cannot shake the image of you turning from me in the years to come, weary of the burdens I laid upon you.

I do not want to be a parent you flee from, yet I also cannot be one who leaves you unprepared. How does one protect without overbearing? This is a question I face daily, a weight that does not lessen. It fills me with awe, the responsibility of loving, guiding, and shaping you—an awe tinged with the sorrow that perhaps I am not enough.

The truth is, I am only a man—nothing more. The world may have taught me much, may have made me wise in its hard ways, but it has left me vulnerable too.

To be your father is to stand exposed, bare before my own doubts and weaknesses, and to say, in a voice quiet yet unwavering: I do not know. It is a terrifying vulnerability to bear, but I have come to see that this, too, is a kind of strength.

To pause, to reflect, to confess uncertainty—is this not a form of bravery? And so, I ask you to forgive me, for I am still learning, still growing alongside you, and I do so with a heart filled with nothing but love.

The line I seek, the line that separates pushing from nurturing, may indeed not exist in any fixed place. Perhaps it is a shifting boundary, one we redraw with each new day, each new interaction.

And perhaps, in my stumbling and struggling, I am teaching you as much as when I speak clearly. Life does not come to us in absolutes; it is often blurred, ambiguous, and filled with choices that leave marks no matter the direction taken.

If I have misstepped, if I have pressed too hard or demanded too much, then let this be my solemn plea: forgive your father, for he loves you with all the strength he has, even in his uncertainty.

I will keep striving, my beloved children, to stand beside you, to guide without overshadowing, to strengthen without breaking. I will keep asking, keep questioning, keep striving to be better.

I am here for you—not as a perfect pillar but as a flawed human who loves you fiercely and is willing to bear the weight of his own doubts so that you might step forth, unburdened, into the world.

And should you, too, stumble or fall, I will be there, not to lift you or push you forward, but to walk alongside you, just as I hope you will one day walk with me, in love and understanding.

And yet, with all the emotion and the fear as I set down these words, I am overwhelmed by a profound gratitude for each of you. You are the light that guides me through the fog of my own imperfections.

For every moment I have faltered, there you have been, with your innocence, your curiosity, and your boundless ability to forgive. You teach me each day what no world of battles or hardships ever could: how to love with gentleness, how to find strength in tenderness, how to listen in silence and learn from the quiet presence of those who trust me so fully.

How could I express the depth of my thanks for the privilege of watching you grow, of hearing your laughter ring out, of witnessing your wonder at this wide, unfathomable world?

You are my quiet joy, the quiet, steady beating of my heart. I am grateful beyond words for the chance to stumble and rise in your presence, for the grace you unknowingly extend to me simply by being yourselves.

Thank you, my beloved ones, for the love that you give so freely, for the forgiveness you offer without being asked, and for the beauty that you bring into every corner of my life. You are my greatest treasure, and for you, I am endlessly grateful.

With all the love I possess,

Your Father

---

---

Found value in these words? Want to dive deeper into the raw, unfiltered truths of life as seen through a father's eyes?

🌟 Join the "Dad Explains" family today! Don’t Forget to share!🌟

Subscribe for free to get full access to our heartfelt, gritty, and honest explorations of life's ups and downs. Every subscription, free or paid, is a cherished support in our journey. For those who choose to contribute, know that your paid subscriptions play a vital role in keeping the quality high, helping cover costs for essential tools like Adobe and other editing software.

But more than that, your support keeps the spirit of "Dad Explains" alive and thriving, ensuring that every story, every lesson, and every piece of dad wisdom reaches you in its most authentic and polished form.

Got questions or thoughts to share? Feel free to drop a comment below or send me an email at dad@dadexplains.life. Your insights, stories, and questions are what make this community a rich tapestry of shared experiences and wisdom. Let's keep the conversation going!

Subscribe today and be a part of a community where every voice matters, every story counts, and every fatherly piece of advice is a step towards understanding the complexities of life.

---