On Structure (ver. 2)

Freedom and structure are often intertwined.

Nov 04, 2024

Man is not a machine that can be remodelled for quite other purposes as occasion demands, in the hope that it will go on functioning as regularly as before but in a quite different way. He carries his whole history with him; in his very structure is written the history of mankind.

Carl Jung

Got a question or message for "Hey Dad"? Submit it anonymously!

I understand the importance of privacy and want to make it easy for you to reach out. You can submit your questions or messages completely anonymously using this form. Just click the link below. I look forward to hearing from you!

Submit Your Anonymous Message Here

**Quick note - This is a re-write of a portion of this book published Aug. 17, 2023

That can be read here.

Now, let’s begin the core content of “Dad’s Guidebook”.**

On Structure

Structure is the invisible scaffolding upon which human life and society build their meaning and purpose. Without structure, there is only chaos; without freedom, structure becomes a prison. In every realm—personal growth, relationships, and cultural evolution—structure provides a foundation, while freedom breathes life into that foundation.

To overlook structure is to ignore the fundamental patterns that support our deepest aspirations and collective achievements. It is not merely a counterpoint to freedom, but a fundamental element in the unfolding of human stability, growth, and creativity.

It would be a mistake, however, to perceive freedom and structure as forces in opposition. Structure is necessary for freedom, just as freedom is essential to the vitality of structure.

By structure, I refer to the intentional frameworks—the rules, rituals, habits, and systems—that support our endeavors and give form to our lives. Freedom, in contrast, is the capacity to explore beyond boundaries, to think, act, and create unbounded by constraint. Rather than being adversarial, these elements are profoundly symbiotic, each enlivening and refining the other.

The difficulty lies in how we, as individuals and as societies, find the balance that maximizes both freedom and structure. In an ideal world, we might reach a harmonious synergy between the two, but often, it is a delicate tension, an oscillating dynamic that we may master temporarily but lose with equal ease.

Consider, for instance, a simple metaphor: the seesaw or teeter-totter. In childhood, one often learns that a seesaw operates in duality; as one child rises, the other falls. But with practice, children begin to understand that it is possible, through skill and cooperation, to find a midpoint where both can hover suspended, neither rising nor falling. This balance requires teamwork, precision, and mutual intent—though the moment it is achieved, it is delicate and, without continuous coordination, quickly lost.

In much the same way, societies have sought this balance, though the process is rarely smooth. Like a seesaw’s movement, societies often shift between extremes, veering from periods of intense structure to eras of unfettered freedom. This cycle of over-correction reflects our collective habit of reacting to imbalance by swinging to the opposite extreme, hoping each time to finally achieve a stable equilibrium.

From the raw chaos of early civilizations, humanity instinctively sought order, constructing the pillars of law, culture, and tradition to hold the chaos at bay. But as structure solidified, so did rigidity, and in time, what once safeguarded freedom began to stifle it.

Over centuries, we have repeatedly learned this lesson: too much structure leads to oppression, too much freedom to disarray. Each generation seems compelled to wrestle anew with this tension, aiming for balance yet propelled by the undertow of historical patterns.

On a personal level, the same dynamic holds true. The balance between freedom and structure lies at the heart of mature self-governance, as we seek both the stability of a firm foundation and the liberty of self-expression. Structure, when applied thoughtfully, nurtures growth; daily rituals or disciplined practices create a reliable base, enabling freedom to flourish without dissolving into chaos. To develop one’s inner balance is to build a stable core that supports both personal and creative freedom, fostering resilience and a harmony between duty and aspiration.

In learning to balance structure with freedom, one develops an intimacy with this delicate equilibrium. At first, the balance may feel elusive, a passing state reached only momentarily. But as familiarity with it grows, the ability to return to this balance becomes almost intuitive, enabling us to anchor ourselves in the quiet stability that structure brings, while embracing the expansive potential that freedom allows.

To master this balance is to live in alignment with one’s highest potential. It is not a final achievement but an evolving, lifelong practice. By striving to return to this balance again and again, we unlock not only a profound self-mastery but also a freedom unknown to many and unachievable by most—a freedom anchored in purpose, a freedom both liberated and bounded by its own constructive constraints. The delicate interplay between freedom and structure, sought consistently, becomes the groundwork of a well-lived life.

On Structure (ver. 2)

Freedom and structure are often intertwined.

On Structure

Discussion about this post